Showing posts with label Rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rules. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Arbitrary

The more I've been watching gymnastics lately, the more I'm kind of getting miffed that things (i.e. rules) are not more standardized. I mean, gymnasts basically give up their entire youth to dedicate it to their sport. And it seems like, depending on what era it has been throughout history, results could have been drastically different than they are.

Let's take the '89-'92 Quad. Well, you didn't have to nail two vaults in the all-around because you got to drop your lowest score. Good thing, since gymnasts like Onodi fell on one of them in the '92 Olympic AA (I know she wasn't going to win an AA medal, but still...). And, by the same token, good thing in the '06-08 Quad, Nastia didn't need two different vaults like gymnasts did in the '97-'00 Quad, or she might have been screwed.

And in the '89-'92 Quad, even if your difficulty hypothetically went over a 10.0, if you made a big enough mistake, it didn't matter. Risk did not necessarily = reward. Look at Kim Gwang Suk's uneven bar routine in event finals. (Why this didn't at least get a bronze, btw, is beyond me). (The fact that she was prob. underage aside).

And, I mean, technically, it's always been the rule that pirouettes on uneven bars should end in handstand. But this was never enforced until '06. Well, gee, that sure did come in handy for the 5 previous years for the Romanians. In fact, form in general was conveniently ignored for a good while, at least as compared to the degree to which it's considered important now.

And what about ties? In '92 they were allowed, and there were several. If memory serves me, wasn't there a 3-way tie for bronze on FX. WTF? Now, we go to obscure tie-breaking means, as in Beijing with Nastia & He Kexin. But had that been 16 years earlier, a tie would have been no big deal! And why is it that when there's a tie for say, second place (back in the day when ties were allowed), there's no bronze medal given? There's still technically someone whose score was third-best and it's not her fault that the 2 of the 3 people above her tied. Someone is getting screwed out of receiving a medal. And remember the days when falling meant losing the chance of winning a medal? Well, no more since Shanshan won a medal at the '07 Worlds and Cheng Fei won bronze on vault in Beijing. But, if the rules had allowed such things in the past, then who knows, Mo Huilan may have won a medal in the AA in Sabae at the '95 Worlds! Even minuscule obscure rules like I think in '95 at National level competition, gymnasts got .1 bonus for doing 2 different vaults. And what about the Phelps vault, the thing I abhor more than any other skill... no one really enforced the layout position (deducting for pike), nor did anyone pay attention to the twisting direction! IG had a good write up on this in '97 or '98, in which they concluded that, depending on the direction in which the gymnast twists, it could be considered two different vaults, and that technically, Amanar was the only one performing it correctly! Did no one care about rules?!

Arg, it's just frustrating how arbitrary some things can be.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Top Three

Recently, The Couch Gymnast asked its readers to tell her what one thing they coud change about gymnastics, if they could change anything. I emailed her one, then a second thing, but I think I actually have three. OK, in order:

1. The 2-per-country rule (already went over this, affirmative action for sports)
2. 3-up-3-count (already went over this, not the best judge of who the strongest team is)
3. Vault. I actually think vault was harder in the '97-'00 quad, form aside (they didn't critique on form then like they do now). Seriously, you couldn't get by in the aforementioned quad with just a Yurchenko 1.5, and even if that was just one of your vaults, it was only worth a 9.7 (or 9.8?). Not to pick on Nastia, but really? She won an Olympic gold medal with that vault? Yeah it was pretty much perfect but in my opinion, she really needed more difficulty.

Which kind of reminds me of something else. I'm all for promoting good form. But really, Nastia getting a 9.2-something in Beijing for her stuck 1.5 Yurchenko? Eh? I watched the 2005 National last night and A-Sac turned is one of the most terrific floor exercises ever, with a triple twist that will rival Maria Olaru -- no leg crossing, no bent knees, got it all the way around -- and got a 9.9. Tim & Elfi went nuts, but moreover, she DESERVED it. Do a good routine, get rewarded for it. During that telecast, Tim mentioned that he wished the old scoring system would return. I wonder how he feels now?

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

And another thing...

I really dislike the 2-per-country rule. It's like affirmative action for sports, and as far as I'm concerned, sports is about competition. May the best girl win!

Now, let's look at the '08 Olympics. In most events, it wasn't a big deal, but look at BB.

1. LI Shanshan CHINA 16.125 Q
2. LIUKIN Nastia USA 15.975 Q
3. JOHNSON Shawn USA 15.975 Q
4. SACRAMONE Alicia USA 15.950
5. FEI Cheng CHINA 15.875 Q
6. PAVLOVA Anna RUSSIA 15.825 Q
7. AFANASYEVA Ksenia RUSSIA 15.775 Q
8. SEMENOVA Ksenia RUSSIA 15.775
9. DENG Linlin CHINA 15.550
10. SLOAN Bridget USA 15.500
11. YANG Yilin CHINA 15.500
12. DRAGOI Gabriela ROMANIA 15.450 Q
13. TSURUMI Koko JAPAN 15.425 Q


In my opinion, should Gragoi and Tsurimi REALLY have qualified? WHY, when A-Sac qualified FOURTH?! I mean, for all we know, A-Sac could have redeemed herself. But more importantly, look at #8-11, all of whom qualified above Dragoi and Tsurimi. What on earth? You know, I know the point of the rule -- to prevent one country dominating. But so what? Let's assume it finished:

Johnson
Liukin
A-Sac

So what? If the Americans really were the best, then so be it. In the actual final, Cheng Fei (bronze) scored a 15.95, same as A-Sac. So, hypothetically, A-Sac might have been in contention for a medal.

Photobucket